How to Choose the Right Shutters for Your Home

How to Choose the Right Shutters for Your Home

Installing shutters can transform the look and feel of your home’s exterior. With so many options, selecting the right shutters that fit your home’s style and needs can be overwhelming. Follow this guide to learn how to pick the perfect shutters to enhance your home’s curb appeal.

Shutters for Bathroom

What Are the Different Types of Shutters?

There are several common types of shutters to consider:

Wood Shutters

Made of basswood, poplar, cedar, or other woods. They have a classic, timeless look and are very durable. However, they require regular maintenance, such as painting or staining.

Vinyl Shutters

Made of PVC, these are more affordable and low-maintenance than wood. They hold their color well but may have been a more natural look.

Composite Shutters

Blend polymers and wood fibers for durability and customizable finishes. It is more scratch-resistant than vinyl but less natural-looking than wood. 

Aluminum Shutters

Lightweight, rust-proof, and very durable. Often used for storm protection on beach houses. It could be more decorative looking. 

Faux Wood Shutters

Vinyl or composite is designed to imitate the look of real wood shutters. Offer a lower maintenance alternative.

What Are the Most Popular Styles of Shutters?

Consider both the functionality and visual appeal of different shutter styles:

do shutters increase home value

Louvre Shutters 

Slanted slat design that allows airflow. Available as fixed louvers or operable ones that tilt open. 

Raised Panel Shutters

Classic style with a frame and center panel. Conveys a formal, elegant look.

Board and Batten Shutters

Rustic style with vertical boards and horizontal battens. Great for cottage or farmhouse aesthetics.

Bahama Shutters

Hinged at the top and angled out to provide shade and ventilation. Ideal for patios and decks.

Café-Style Shutters

Bi-fold shutters that cover the lower half of windows. Provide privacy while allowing light in.

Cutout Shutters

Decorative option with cutout shapes or patterns. Let in dappled light beautifully.

Shaped Shutters

Custom shutters are made to match unique window shapes like circles, arches, and triangles.

What Factors Should You Consider When Choosing Shutters?

Assess the following criteria to select the best shutters for your specific home:


Match the architectural style of your home. Formal homes suit raised panels, while cottages fit board and batten. 

Window size

To match the window height and width, scale the shutter size proportionally.

Privacy needs

Bahama and café-style provide coverage, while louvers allow some visibility. 

Climate conditions

Bahama shutters ventilate humid climates, while louvers allow airflow. 

Exposure to elements

Select durable, high-quality materials if shutters endure sun, rain, and saltwater.


Match or complement your home’s color scheme. Neutrals like white or black are versatile. 


Wood shutters are premium, while composite and vinyl cost less. Prioritize visible front-facing windows.

DIY vs. professional installation

Consider your skills and tools if installing shutters yourself.

Matching architecture

Choose a style that enhances your home’s existing architectural details.

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing Shutters

Do you still have questions about selecting the ideal shutters? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:

1. What’s the best way to measure for shutters?

Use a tape measure to measure the exact height and width of each window opening. Provide these measurements to the shutter company for custom-fit shutters.

Pricing depends on material and custom sizing, but expect to pay $25 – $75 per square foot installed. Wood is the most expensive. Vinyl and composite cost less but vary by quality.

Matching the shutter color to the trim is recommended for a cohesive look. Contrasting the shutter and siding colors helps the windows stand out.

Choose the Right Shutters for Your Home

how to pick shutters for your house

Shutters provide charm, ventilation, light control, and security. They can boost curb appeal far more than plain curtains or blinds. Take time to find well-crafted shutters suited to your home’s style. Quality installation also helps shutters maximize benefits while lasting for years to come. 

When carefully selected, shutters become integral to a home’s character. Whether you prefer natural wood, low-maintenance vinyl, or chic faux wood, keep your home’s architecture and design style in mind. Seek experts to ensure proper measurements for custom fits tailored to your windows. Investing in the right shutters truly pays off when you love glancing up at your home’s facade.

Contact the experts at Made in the Shade Hilton Head for personalized guidance on finding the perfect custom shutters. With many years of experience, our team helps homeowners select exquisite shutters suited to their home’s unique style and needs. Schedule a design consultation today to get started designing your dream shutters.